I have chewed and digested this movie for several weeks now. It was good, but wasn’t great…and certainly not as good as the book. To me, the movie had a feel of an “indy” (independently made movie). I wanted to love it. I wanted to be so awed that I couldn’t speak. Don’t get my wrong…I gasped when Edward entered the cafeteria. I sighed when they finally kissed and squealed when I first saw Jacob. I wanted more and ultimately, I left feeling very unsatisfied which, truth be told, is typically part of my nature. (or so I have been told).
Let’s call my critique: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.
Let’s start with the bad and the ugly.
I felt the movie moved too fast, especially the relationship between Bella and Edward. I wanted to watch them fall in love. I wanted to see her persistence and Edward giving in to his feelings despite himself.
I was irritated that they used film time to add superfluous characters and added the killings by the rogue vampires just to add heightened drama. It was pointless to the story; nothing to do with the plot.
The fact that they depicted Edward "flying" when really he could only run very fast (not fly or climb trees) was ridiculous; and the effects, for that matter, did not seem very ‘large budget’.
I hated that they took the meadow scene and had it following Edward and Bella arguing and Edward upset...when in the book it is a very touching scene where they realize they love each other and he takes her to the meadow on a date, their first real date, to reveal himself. (Not to mention he sparkled in the book much more brilliantly than in the movie.)
Bella continually insists that she isn’t scared but is in awe and very intrigued by the Cullens; but throughout the movie she did seem scared, in pain, and very jittery. The fact that she spoke almost entirely in incomplete sentences drove me insane! It was as if her thoughts were incomplete but while her character might have been very clumsy in body but she was very certain in mind of what she felt, thought, and wanted.
There was never a mention of the Volturi or the Denail Clan throughout the entire film.
Several important plot points that were left out of the film:
They left out Bella's dream about her grandmother which was important since her "realization" that she would grow old while Edward wouldn't was the real reason she pushed for someone to change her...and she was pretty pushy about that being done throughout the end of the book...which in the movie she mentions ONCE.
They didn't show the biology lab about blood typing where Bella faints...and the whole irony of her being 'sick at the sight and smell of blood' but in love with a vampire is kind of humorous not to mention a great example of foreshadowing for what comes in the other books.
I hated that they left out her birthday party and the paper cut. The paper cut was the whole reason Edward left in New Moon; therefore leaving the door wide open for the budding relationship between Bella and Jacob. Following the ending in the book would have been a much better and more accurate ending than seeing Victoria at prom.
I was very upset that there was no mention of the tour of Carlisle’s office, his family cross (again, great example of irony), and his history of becoming a vampire. That point is important to the plot because it was that reason they were 'vegetarian' to begin with.
There was no mention of Alice's history and lack of memory regarding her life…especially since it was James' doing to begin with and one of the reasons he felt his killing of Bella was poetic justice.
There was not much chemistry between Alice & Bella and the film did not allow that bond to blossom.
One of the funniest parts of the book is when Edward & Bella are in his room and Alice & Jasper come in and Alice says something like, “It sounded like you were having Bella for a snack and we wanted to see if you would share!” That wit is what made us all fall in love with the Cullen/Hale family and we didn’t see much, if any, of that in the film.
The initial meeting of Bella and Jacob was to take place at the bonfire on the beach and his telling her the "scary story" made more sense at night than them surfing during the day. (I'm being picky, I know.)
The time spent in the hotel and her 'escaping' from the airport was cut to minutes instead of lengthened to create the nerve wracking waiting and intensity that actually took place.
The character of Jasper all together was totally “Edward Scissorhands-esque” in the film...Hello?? Did he have more than 3 lines in the movie??
The fact that Bella was in her underwear when they kissed in her bedroom really annoyed me because she was much more reserved in her appearance, lacked the confidence it would take to kiss someone (for the first time) while wearing your undergarments, and I believe their first kiss was in a car.
They left out the whole spring dance and went straight to prom then left out the humor of Edward causing the traffic jam so Tyler could ask her to prom and then the real humor of Tyler showing up to pick her up for prom.
Okay, finally the good.
Here is what I loved:
The soundtrack. I will admit that I listened to many songs before the movie and already loved the fact that Rob Pattinson sang two songs on the soundtrack.
Charlie (I didn't think I would like the actor that played him but I loved him!)
Emmett (He was fabulous and just spot on with that character!)
Edward (of course, he certainly has that sad brooding down PAT and he is so hot especially when he smiles...holy cow.)
Carlisle (Good call on casting, appeared about 10 years older than in the book which was more believable so I didn’t mind that change.)
The supporting cast (all the kids from school were hilarious!)
James (He was spot on...hot, sexy, and scary as all get out!)
Jacob. I just love Jacob...love, love, love me some Jacob. I can't wait to watch his character grow and evolve and hopefully they will stay true to his character. I did, for some reason, imagine him with short hair and still very boyish looking in Twilight, then becoming manlier with longer, wilder hair in New Moon.
I guess I am a purist and want it to follow the book exactly. The book read well enough alone that it should have just been transferred to the screen. No need to change, add or delete anything. In the end, this saga works because of the nuances within all the relationships so I hope the films for New Moon and Eclipse are longer so they can stay true to the plot, story line, relationships, and details.